Guest Reviews

Our guests are the best!
Read Reviews

Reviews from Our Guest Books

Hand written reviews from our guests. 

  • Castnetter Review 6

    Castnetter Review 6

  • Castnetter Review 7

    Castnetter Review 7

  • Castnetter Review 6

    Castnetter Review 6

  • Castnetter Review 7

    Castnetter Review 7

  • Castnetter Review 8

    Castnetter Review 8

  • Castnetter Review 9

    Castnetter Review 9

  • Castnetter Review 10

    Castnetter Review 10

  • Castnetter Review 11

    Castnetter Review 11

    Reviews from Partner Sites

    TripAdvisor Reviews

    • star rating  Castnetter Beach Resort was perfect for our Family trip. Couldn't have picked a better spot. I travel for a living and have stayed at some of the top resorts in... read more

      Zootstinsky
      May 13, 2017
    • star rating  We stayed in Castnetters #2, which, having never been to AMI before and not knowing the locale, turned out to be a bit of a surprise. This was a condo... read more

      nancypakahazel
      May 2, 2016
    • star rating  We loved our stay at the Castnetter Beach Resort!! The perfect place for a family vacation!! Plenty of room, very very clean and well decorated. We all enjoyed the pool... read more

      David S
      August 31, 2016
    • star rating  Great rest and relaxation! Sunshine and smiles ! First time visiting the Island and staying for a few nights. Great people , food, and location. Was hard to leave but... read more

      Sueusafw
      July 19, 2016
    • star rating  Absolutely outstanding. The unit is updated and offers EVERY possible thing you would ever need. You really do not have to bring anything. Alan and Donna were there and... read more

      grmgr5
      July 18, 2016
    • star rating  We stayed here for 5 nights with our 2 grand kids and their parents. The location was great, just across the street from the beach. The unit was very clean... read more

      mkh303
      June 16, 2018
    • star rating  We loved this place! Very clean and beautifully decorated. The pool was wonderful to be able to go to with our kids and the beach and trolley stop were right... read more

      shasha333
      May 5, 2021
    • star rating  We loved our stay on Anna Maria Island! The condo was very conveniently located across the street from the public beach so we were able to enjoy the sun and... read more

      Mfowler32
      September 27, 2016
    • star rating  Castnetter Beach Resort was a great place to stay. We stayed in unit number 5 which is a two bedroom two bath unit. It's on the second floor and has... read more

      Brian S
      March 24, 2017
    • star rating  This little villa was perfect for our little family of 4. It had plenty of space and the pool was excellent. The owners, Donna and Gary were VERY... read more

      Tara C
      May 2, 2016
    Castnetter Beach Resorts
    4.0
    Based on 19 reviews
    powered by Google
    Tara Risner
    Tara Risner
    04:40 13 Jul 21
    I can’t say enough about this hidden gem. I have visited twice in the last three months. Once on a girls trip and... another with my family of four. I don’t typically write reviews but after reading a few negative ones I felt inspired. This place is beautiful. Private pool and across from Manatee beach. Anything you could possibly need is so convenient. This beach is in my top three and I’ve traveled a lot of places. The house is clean and modern. Also has anything you may need. Bonus* rafts and beach umbrellas and all you could ever ask for in the kitchen. The owner’s are so amazing. Alan and Donna are attentive and super down to earth and made our experience special. Thanks again Donna and Alan we had an incredible vacation last week.Xo Tara RisnerSee you next spring!!!read more
    Gina Fanuzzi
    Gina Fanuzzi
    14:18 04 Mar 20
    This review is referring to the blue building at 4101 Gulf Dr.The sign in front of our unit says Castnetter Beach... Resorts but the rental is called Castaways 1 and 2 (2 units)We arrived at our rental after an 8 hour drive February 1st. We had booked the unit for a month . We found the following1. Broken toilet paper dispenser.2. Shower faucet was loose3.Lamp Broken in master bedroom4 Several Electrical outlet without cover and not secured to wall and/or not working5 All Windows Filthy, some never got cleaned after complained because cleaners couldn’t reach. Sandy said she would send someone, no one came. Reminded Terry. Never got done. Even after some windows were cleaned they still appeared dirty as they were so old and etched6. Closet bifold door did not close as too close to floor7. Paint peeling on ceiling8. Filthy throw pillows that hadn’t been washed.9. Filthy upholstered bench10 Upholstered couch and chair needs cleaning11 Carpet needs cleaning12. Light bulbs missing13 Kitchen sink pipe leaking under sink and causing bad smell and very poor water pressure which was resolved when plumber cameFeb 514.Listing described “updated designer kitchen” when in fact cupboards were from 1960s, gaps were cupboards met ceiling, no blind on window above sink. Terry has since changed his ad. but I have a screen print of the original ad.15.Fridge gasket was unattached and hanging.16. Stove old style burners didn’t hold pots and pans flat. Egg would end up on one side of pan.17 Inadequately stocked kitchen No large bowls18.Ad stated picnic table and there was no picnic table and after complaining one was never brought19.BBQ was filthy old and rusty.20.One small chair with no arms on balcony.21.Noises in walls from animals.22.Entry door not appear secure, frame gouged like someone broke in, key lock broken, weatherstripping hanging, a lot of people have combo for combo lock, maids, handyman , plumber, electrician. Suspect he never changes it as was given combo on Dec 4 when arriving on Feb 1. No Safe in unit to store valuables in lieu of this.23. Outdoor stair light not working.24.dirty fingerprints throughout the unit25Terry would often say he had to contact the owner, Mark, in order to get out of doing things when in fact we find out, he is the owner and Mark was the previous owner.26.Terry left the information info binder that the previous owners supplied, that contained information on who to call if there is a problem, etc. When we called, they said they haven’t handled this property for some time and the binder should have been removed26. When we met our neighbours in the adjoining unit, Castaways 2, they also had a shopping list of complaints, including the shared complaint regarding the animals in the walls.We had to spend some of our vacation at the unit while they fixed things as there was no trust in the owner and no Safe to put our valuables. This all caused me a lot of stress and anxiety which lingered throughout our vacation and we also lost sleep between the anxiety and noises from animals in walls.I asked Terry for compensation. His reply was, we got the place for a discount of 3,749.00 when we booked it which is a lie. I went on line and booked next year 2021 on AIRBNB for the same time period and was given a price of $6,604.00. We paid $6500.00. Where is the so called 3,749.00 discount? Besides, The so called discount we got back in November wasn’t compensation for what we where unknowingly about to go through, it was for taking the unit for an entire month. We would have never booked it for any price if we would have know what we were getting into and who we would have to deal with.Terry is always on vacation. It is either a lie or his way of getting out of doing thingsTerry and Sandy have several properties. I think they are irresponsible owners and only care about their vacation and no one else’s. I want to warn other potential renters or have These owners learn to treat their renters with respect.read more
    Mark Rudek
    Mark Rudek
    16:32 24 Feb 20
    This Beach Resort does not pay their bills. I worked on an old pool heater in bad shape. I told Alan Gary that I did... not advise trying to fix it. He said he wanted me to replace the motor, so I did. He agreed to pay the bill no matter what the outcome. Now he owes me $500 and will not answer the phone or text me back. Now I have to sue him. Stay far away from this unscrupulous character. He's a bad eggread more
    Joshua Church
    Joshua Church
    21:10 21 Sep 18
    Very close to beach so location is great. Love thw rooms and service is good
    Sandra Smith
    Sandra Smith
    00:06 30 Jul 18
    A flip key resort. The accommodations are great, neat, clean roomy surprisingly low cost for what you get.
    K Vance
    K Vance
    01:06 15 Jun 17
    Excellent vacation spot. Across the street from the beach. Very clean and comfortable.
    Next Reviews